Global Research Institute holds panel, discusses Norwegian Labour and Welfare Administration

Wednesday, Nov. 11, the College of William and Mary’s Global Research Institute and anthropology department co-sponsored a panel in the McKenzie Theater to discuss anthropology assistant professor Kelly McKowen’s book, “Down and Out of Utopia.” Panelists included government professor Hannah Alarian, sociology professor Caroline Hanley and McKowen. Global Research Institute Senior Research Manager Martin Aucoin moderated the conversation.

McKowen said how he followed 30 individuals — both immigrants and native citizens — as they received support from the Norwegian Labour and Welfare Administration between 2014 and 2016. 

“In addition to spending a lot of time in job seizure sources and kind of casually with the unemployed, I also spent extensive time in NAV offices, visiting them, touring them hanging out with their employees,” McKowen said. “I was very fortunate in that I got to know the leader of a local NAV user organization really well, and she invited me to shadow the organization for basically a year.” 

Following McKowen’s presentation, Hanley and Alarian shared their initial thoughts on the book. 

Hanley noted differences in the relationship between worth and employment for Americans versus Norwegians. 

“Americans identify with work as a sign of moral worth, while Norwegians seem to locate worth in employment, a subtle but important difference,” Hanley said. 

Hanley noted that the book did not mention employers and criticized McKowen for failing to acknowledge market capital as a reason for unemployment. 

“If Norwegians narrate unemployment as being more foundationally about their relation to the state than the market, then I would like to see that point dug out a little bit more,” Hanley said. 

Alarian drew ties to American immigration. She said she believes the Norwegian welfare system exemplifies social citizenship. 

“In NAV offices and job search courses, people learn what membership in Norway means in practice,” she said. “Work is valued, the state is a partner and what it means to have rights and obligations runs both ways.”

Aucoin then opened the floor to audience questions.

In response to a question about the Norwegian dream, McKowen described it as a process of people working, paying taxes and then benefiting from the welfare system.

“They’re pre-cut tracks in the snow,” McKowen said. “If you put your skis in those tracks and you just follow them, you’re gonna have a pretty good ski.” 

Alarian was also hesitant to say there exists a specific Norwegian dream. Instead, she said she believes connections and family ties brought European migrants to Norway.

“The connection to work is critical because it signals something meaningful: that the economy, the employer, society, potentially the state has recognized that they’re worthy and they belong and they have something to contribute to this,” she said. “I’m not sure how much that is unique to Norway or to Germany or to any other European state or maybe to the United States as well.” 

Aucoin asked how arguments about welfare chauvinism have played out across Europe and in the United States.

Alarian pointed to the relationship between the people and the state in a welfare system like Norway’s, emphasizing how part of the Norwegian citizenry requires collective community participation. She said she believes asking the question of welfare chauvinism is also questioning the entire system.

“Welfare chauvinism puts into question, and to a problem, ‘If we don’t have this, are we distinguishing no migrants or no specific migrants?’” Alarian said. “It’s a slippery slope to what point next, and then you’re just completely disintegrating this unified connection between the state and the resident.”

Related News

Subscribe to the Flat Hat News Briefing!

* indicates required