Poll provides insight into student opinions on administration, public safety

Wednesday, Nov. 4 and Thursday, Nov. 5, The Flat Hat conducted a poll to gauge undergraduate students’ sentiments on issues relevant to the College of William and Mary, including administrative approval and campus safety.

To administer the poll, staff members were stationed at three locations — Sadler Terrace, outside Earl Gregg Swem Library and outside Commons Dining Hall — from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. both days. Respondents completed identical Google Forms using links that were updated hourly. This measure was intended to discourage participants from sharing the poll with their peers, which could have resulted in coordinated responses or the overrepresentation of certain groups.

The Flat Hat received 777 unique responses. This represents approximately 11.2% of the undergraduate student body, according to the University Data Fact Book from fall 2025. No current or former Flat Hat staff members or interns participated in the poll. Results were not weighted to reflect the College’s undergraduate population’s demographics.

Out of the 777 respondents, 22% were members of the class of 2027, 21.4% were members of the class of 2028, 29.2% were members of the class of 2029 and 27.4% were members of the class of 2030.

More than one-third of respondents reported they neither approve nor disapprove of College President Katherine Rowe’s leadership, while 33% said they somewhat approve. Similarly, 36% of respondents reported they have a fair amount of confidence in the College’s administrative leadership, while 33% expressed neutral opinions. The College’s leadership includes the president, provost, director of athletics, executive vice president for Finance and Administration, senior vice president for Student Affairs and Public Safety, and senior vice president of University Advancement.

Members of the class of 2030 were most likely to strongly approve of Rowe and express confidence in the College’s leadership, while members of the class of 2027 were least likely to do so.

Spencer Mann ’30 and Terrence McDuffie ’27 attributed this difference to the number of years spent on campus.

“I don’t have a reason to disapprove yet, whereas maybe some upperclassmen who have been here longer might have a reason to disapprove at this point,” Mann said. “I’d say mostly freshmen are really happy to be here and have innately positive impressions.”

McDuffie, also a class of 2027 senator, echoed the sentiment.

“We’ve gotten to know the ‘ins and outs’ of the university over the past four years, and I’ve seen some things that could’ve gone better, could’ve gone worse,” he added.

McDuffie said the 2023-24 academic year particularly shaped his view of Rowe. 

“There were specific moments in time in which the president didn’t listen to us despite the majority of students voicing their own perspectives and looking toward the president as someone who would represent our voices,” he said.

McDuffie cited the passage of a March 2024 student-led referendum calling on the College to audit its endowment and divest from companies linked to Israel amid ongoing conflict at the Gaza strip as an example. The following day, Rowe said in a statement that the College “would not pursue a boycott of Israel as proposed in the student referendum,” noting that most investment decisions involving College-affiliated endowments are made by the 1693 Partners Fund board.

Melissa Moyer ’29 said she believes Rowe could do more to engage with students.

“If she really wants to understand the students, she at least needs to make more of an effort to meet us,” she added.

While 41% of respondents who were not Division I athletes said they strongly or somewhat approved of Rowe, 65% of Division I student-athletes approved.

Michael Weiner ’28, a member of the men’s gymnastics team, credited this to a possible lack of knowledge about Rowe among student-athletes.

“I really don’t know much about Rowe in terms of her policies and whatnot,” he said. “Athletes could be less informed.”

Weiner added that Rowe’s attendance at certain athletic events — such as football and basketball games — could also have influenced student-athletes’ responses.

The Flat Hat also asked respondents about campus safety measures, including Timely Warning emails and Flock cameras.

Eighty-one percent of respondents expressed support for the College’s use of Timely Warning emails. Issued by Public Safety, these messages notify the community about on-campus crimes specified in the Clery Act. 

Respondents were informed that these warnings are issued on a case-by-case basis and do not include personally identifiable information.

Mann highlighted the recent Cornell University case as a reason for his support.

“I think it’s very important for students to know what’s going on,” he said.

Other students, including Moyer, said that these notifications might foster a heightened sense of fear among students.

The majority of respondents said they strongly disapproved of the William and Mary Police Department’s use of Flock cameras — automatic license plate readers that scan and log identifiable vehicle information — on campus. 

Respondents were informed that campus police are no longer listed as sharing Flock camera data with law enforcement partners, per the College’s Flock Transparency Portal.

Mann said his disapproval stems from concerns about artificial intelligence and the prospect of constant surveillance.

“The idea of having essentially what is the most powerful machine ever created surveilling you is not something that’s appealing — it’s even a little scary,” he added. “It has the inverse effect, where people feel a lot less safe now that they’re constantly under surveillance.”

The Flat Hat contacted the College’s Executive Director of Media Relations Suzanne Clavet for comment but received no response.

Demographic Information

Maddie Mohamadi
Maddie Mohamadi
Maddie (she/her) is an economics student at William and Mary. As Operations Coordinator, she looks forward to helping interns develop their reporting skills and crafting long-form articles for the paper. On campus, Maddie is also involved in The Monitor Journal of International Studies and the Economics Club.

Related News

Subscribe to the Flat Hat News Briefing!

* indicates required