Response to deck collapse commenters: yes, we study physics

Benjamin Mueller ’30 is a government and data science major. He enjoys skiing, playing soccer and exploring the American West. His favorite thing to read is the food section of the New York Times, and he loves exploring the connection between media literacy, politics and popular culture. You can contact him at bpmueller@wm.edu.

The views expressed in the article are the author’s own.

“Kids these days” is a somewhat common refrain from a slightly older generation to describe youth in America. The phrase does not necessarily have a positive connotation, and it may even be a critique of current popular culture. It may also be used to create an air of superiority and to imply that young people are naive. Recently, a particular off-campus event involving “kids these days” drew national attention when a deck collapsed, injuring 39 students. The incident not only revived conversation about college housing, but it renewed debate about American college education.

Netizens on traditionally right-wing news sites, in particular, had plenty to say. Most comments concerned the structure of the deck, but many comments also involved the structure of our education as students at the College of William and Mary. “This story is not at all uncommon. These students were given gender studies, DEI, and 2+2 = 5 math in high school instead of physics,” user Keepitcivil said in a Fox News comment section concerning the incident. While, in my opinion, this is not the kind of language that “keeps it civil,” Keepitcivil brings up a sentiment shared by many Americans about our education system, whether higher or elementary: College has a negative effect on our country and is not important. According to a 2026 Gallup poll, only 31% of Americans believe that a college education is very important, the lowest percentage since 1978. 

The social sciences are often seen as less societally useful than physical sciences like engineering. They are also generally less lucrative than physical sciences. When a degree’s value is measured only by its expected salary, the reasons for studying sociology or political science can disappear from view.

It becomes especially difficult for people, specifically those further right on the political spectrum, to understand why one might study social science when the social sciences are solely seen as breeding grounds for explicitly leftist thought. Jesse Smith, an assistant professor at Ohio State University, even argues that because conservatives are so unwelcome in the social sciences, conservatives should establish their own social sciences. Smith argues that social science research has an inherent liberal bias, especially on topics like the criminal justice system, and that these disciplines would benefit from a conservative viewpoint.

Here, however, Smith seems to argue that preeminent social sciences were established from a liberal viewpoint, making them exclusive toward conservative scholars. Social science disciplines were not explicitly created, but they evolved through history. Social sciences can develop biases, yes, but this does not mean the discipline is inherently biased. It is simply an ideological reflection of the scholars within a discipline at a given time. Social sciences are simply studies of the world around us, and the results of these surveys may be politically biased for a reason. Smith also makes several important points about research methods that should be considered. There is no reason to create a “conservative social science” because there is no liberal social science. Smith should encourage more conservative social scientists to join the field to create ideological change.

So why should the social sciences, or, as our favorite netizen so aptly put it, “DEI,” be in a conversation about physics? An important aspect of liberal arts education is interdisciplinary coursework. Thus, a student studying physics at the College may find themselves in a “DEI” class. However, contrary to Keepitcivil’s expectations, this is not a detriment to the student’s education. 

According to McMillan Education, one of the primary advantages of a liberal arts education is increased intellectual depth and independent thinking. Primarily, the intellectual depth gained from a liberal arts education provides intrinsic value to an entire society that doesn’t necessarily involve “2 + 2 = 5 math.” The intellectual depth provided by a liberal arts education can be a degree in engineering where one better understands the community they are engineering for, and thus are able to make more effective designs. An engineering degree with an understanding of socioeconomic contexts may seem futile and simpleminded, but consider the following example:

In a suburban college town, an engineering or other STEM degree with cultural context could be especially useful. Understanding the kinds of residences and people occupying these residences could lead to smarter designs, like reinforced decks, for example. Understanding context and the broader world is incredibly useful not only for making our world a better (and more useful) place, but even a physically safer place.

This is not to say a liberal arts education would have prevented the deck collapse because that is a ridiculous argument. The deck collapse was a tragic event based on a variety of factors. A liberal arts education is somewhat aspirational and idealist, and our world doesn’t always conform to this vision. One architect/physicist/city planner with a liberal arts degree cannot solve the world’s problems, especially if they don’t choose to fully take advantage of the critical thinking skills they may have gained from their education. There are infinite conditionals making this a ridiculous and overly idealistic vision, but I use this mainly as a defense of the modern liberal arts education.

Folks like Keepitcivil and other commenters like them, including in the highest echelons of our government, criticize the modern liberal arts education as closed-minded and anti-American. The purpose of the liberal arts, however, is to promote free thinking, which I believe it largely does, especially when professors make a tangible attempt to include and encourage diverse viewpoints. The liberal arts, when properly utilized, provide immense value not only to students, but also to the world students enter. Yes, we may study some subjects that seem ridiculous and even “woke,” but we also study physics that, when applied with these subjects, can make the world a far better place.


Related News

Subscribe to the Flat Hat News Briefing!

* indicates required