You know what we’re talking about. It’s the place you always turn to. Your favorite sandwich, dessert, or late-night snack. The Gobbler. Death By Chocolate. The Ninja Turtle.
It’s comfort food, date food, fast food. It’s beers, margaritas, shaved ice.
It’s the Best of the ’Burg.
The Flat Hat’s annual list features the top eateries in the Williamsburg area. Whether you are a fan of fast and cheap or in the mood for a more romantic meal, this guide provides you with the insight necessary to locate the best dining around the College of William and Mary.
The list is voted on by The Flat Hat’s editorial staff and contains not only the traditional favorites, but a few new winners as well. New categories Best On-The-Go and Best Margarita were captured by WaWa and Tequila Rose, respectively.
In a surprise upset, Paul’s Deli replaced the Green Leafe Cafe as the best deli. But don’t fret, fans of mug night. The Green Leafe hung on to its title as top place to get a beer in Williamsburg.
Other repeats include Nawab, Aromas, the Trellis and the Fat Canary.
**Best Ethnic: Nawab**
Whether you dine at Nawab during its delicious lunchtime buffet or choose something from its extensive menu, you will not be disappointed. The mouth-watering choices at Nawab practically guarantee its place as Best Ethnic Restaurant. The restaurant prepares every dish with flavors that make you feel as if you’ve stepped into New Delhi. The samosas, a definite must-try, are the perfect way to start a meal — these flakey turnovers are stuffed with seasoned potatoes and peas. The spicy flavor of the filling complements the simple taste of the crust. For an entree, you cannot go wrong with the chicken tikka masala — chicken marinated in yogurt, then simmered in a tomato and cream sauce. No meal is complete without a dessert of gulab jamun. These sweet dumplings are served in a cardamom-infused syrup with toasted coconut flakes. If you have a sweet tooth, this is the dessert for you.
— Ashley Morgan
**Best Margarita: Tequila Rose**
Seedy Mexican restaurants have developed into a dearly beloved institution, but Tequila Rose outshines them all. The dim lighting and cat-calling patrons may turn some customers away, but don’t let it get to you. Unbeatable in Williamsburg, the food is divine. The extensive menu, recently revised, includes a Spanish vocabulary section so you know just what you’re ordering. Options range from more expensive entrees to combination meals involving some mix of burritos, tacos, chalupas, enchiladas and the like, to a la carte options. Personal recommendation: Try the chicken quesadillas. Of course, the critical measure of a Mexican restaurant is its margaritas; Tequila Rose does not disappoint. Available in a range of sizes — from nine to 32 ounces — and frozen or on ice, anyone can find the perfect margarita for the moment. Located a ways down Merrimack Trail, it would be quite a hike walking, so make sure to bring a designated driver. It’s well worth the trek.
— Alice Hahn
**Best On-Campus: Marketplace**
While eating at the Caf or the Sadler Center dining hall often feels like eating in a hospital cafeteria, the Marketplace offers a slightly more ambient feel and, at the very least, more choices. Zoca, the Mexican station, is always a good bet for quesadillas and taco salads, especially if Marie or Jamal are working. The chicken tenders and burgers are surprisingly good, and, if that doesn’t sound appetizing, there are always smoothies or a Chick-Fil-A sandwich. In addition, the Starbucks tucked into the corner provides a much-needed source of caffeine on that side of campus. Two complaints: The dessert selection is woefully measly (though occasionally you can catch a parfait or pastry), and Homezone seems to serve no purpose other than to emanate questionable fumes that confirm my long-held belief that vegetables are, in fact, bad for you. However, at present, my five-quesdillas-a-week habit is keeping me a fan of the Marketplace.
— Alexa McClanahan
**Best Breakfast: IHOP**
When it comes to breakfast food, the competitors just can’t touch IHOP. Not only does this place have fantastic omelettes, French toast and pancakes, but it gets bonus points for serving these delicious offerings all day long — not to mention all night long on weekends. Go basic with the breakfast sampler or a Rooty Tooty Fresh ’N Fruity. If you’re feeling more cosmopolitan, try one of the new Nutella crepes or the Danish fruit crepes. For the health-conscious, there’s always an order of the Harvest Grain ’N Nut pancakes or a heart-healthy spinach and mushroom omelette.
As if the tasty food and prices to compliment a College student’s often-depleted bank account weren’t enough to draw you in, IHOP happens to be hosting National Pancake Day today. Visit the Richmond Road or Rochambeau Drive locations any time from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. for a free short stack of the pancakes that made IHOP famous.
— Vanessa VanLandingham
**Best Date Restaurant: Blue Talon Bistro**
Checking in at the top spot of our Best Date Restaurant category is Prince George Street’s Blue Talon Bistro. The upscale restaurant sports the tagline “Serious Comfort Food” and doesn’t disappoint, delivering a menu chock-full of delicious favorites, including the lamb chops ($27.95), seared salmon ($23.95) and their signature mac ’n cheese ($15.95). A dinner for two does end up being pretty pricey, so be sure to save a trip to the Blue Talon for when you really want to impress your favorite guy or gal. A cheaper option: Visit the restaurant for weekend brunch. The food is every bit as delicious, and meals are typically under $15. Be sure to try their meatloaf dish with pork and potato hash, hollandaise and a poached egg. And for the over-21 crowd, you can’t go wrong by kicking off a date with a mimosa or three.
— Jeff Dooley
**Best Frozen Treat: Sno-to-Go**
It’s a typical August day in Williamsburg with temperatures hovering around 90 degrees and humidity just as high. You’re sitting under a tree by the new campus sundial and are still sweating. Only one thing can make your day better: A stuffed snoball from Sno-to-Go.
The incomparable snoball comes in over 40 flavors like Bahama Mama, Nemo and Ninja Turtle. Vanilla soft-serve tops the concoction and fills the center. The soft-serve/shaved ice combo creates a perfect synthesis of flavors and cools you down enough to forget how hot it is.
Located less than 10 minutes from campus on Richmond Road, Sno-to-Go offers more than the snoball. from straight soft-serve to sno-cones, Sno-to-Go delivers refreshment from April to October.
— Andrew Pike
**Best Deli: Paul’s Deli**
It’s not pretentious like the Green Leafe, but it feels like someone mopped the floor last night, unlike the College Delly. Located next to its upscale rival and across from its low-price competitor, Paul’s Deli finds the perfect balance between classy and trashy. You don’t stand in a line to get in, like at the Leafe — but once inside, you find yourself with plenty of company, unlike at College. The wide variety of greasy drunk food that Paul’s offers is exactly what you’ll crave at 1:30 a.m. Friday, or at 9 p.m. Wednesday while watching the Duke-Maryland game on one of the 10 TVs. Not to mention, all of the College sports memorabilia lining the walls makes you feel proud to be part of the Tribe rather than ashamed to live in a city too lame for actual bars.
— Austin Wright
**Best Vegetarian: Nawab**
A vegetarian’s delight, Nawab is located on Monticello Avenue, next to Big Lots. The restaurant offers numerous vegetable-based choices to please vegetarians and vegans alike, making it the obvious choice for Best Vegetarian Restaurant. Two noteworthy choices include vegetable masala and palak paneer. The vegetable masala is a combination of spiced vegetables in a flavorful tomato-cream sauce. Palak paneer involves baked spinach with tender Indian cheeses and herbs and spices. All dishes are served with basmati rice and are best complemented with fresh-baked Naan — soft Indian flatbread. The restaurant also specially prepares entrees on request, changing the intensity of the spices. Diners can request their entree be mild, medium, hot or Indian hot.
— Ashley Morgan
**Best Value, Best Late-Night, Best On-The-Go: Wawa**
Late-night food runs to Wawa, like completing the triathalon or lining up to enter Swem when it opens at 1 p.m. on Sundays, are an unofficial institution at the College of William and Mary. For Wawa regulars, a trip to the convenience store typically involves ordering a sandwich (everyone has their favorites; some can even order from the touch screens blindfolded), perusing the chips aisle, grabbing a coffee, finding a choice alcoholic beverage — for those of age — and, of course, flirting with the checkout girl. For many freshmen, Wawa is a premiere late-night destination; in fact, most Monrovians simply refer to it as the Monroe dining hall. Furthermore, many freshman halls bond during large group outings to the Richmond Road store. Wawa remains a defining feature of many undergraduates’ experiences at the College. How can you tell? It’s more crowded at 2 a.m. than 2 p.m.
But Wawa is like the Williamsburg version of “Slumdog Millionaire” — it’s sweeping myriad categories this year. It’s easy to see why Wawa is Williamsburg’s Best Value. Cheap sandwiches make for inexpensive late-night snacks, and the coffee comes in every size and flavor you could need. As for Best On-The-Go, there’s nowhere else in Williamsburg where you can be in and out in two minutes flat — unless, of course, it’s last call at the nearby delis, in which case you can kiss the next hour goodbye. The only way to make it faster? Wawa Drive-Thru.
— Alex Guillén
**Best Dessert: The Trellis**
When most people think of The Trellis, let’s face it, we all think of dying in a pool of chocolate and gaining about 10 pounds per slice of Death by Chocolate cake. And we all have to admit, chocolate is exquisite. But contrary to popular belief, chocolate isn’t all that the Trellis is about.
For all you chocolate-intolerant people out there, the Trellis actually has a decent selection of non-chocolate desserts including everything from a unique selection of hand-made ice creams and sorbets (try the vanilla mint or strawberry mango), to various cheesecakes and original French-inspired dishes.
For those of you looking for low-fat desserts, not to worry — the menu also includes several fruit options, such as a strawberries and a delicious cream dish.
The only downside is that the desserts are kind of expensive; their prices range from $10 to $15. However, with the quality and taste that can only be provided by The Trellis’s world-famous dessert chef, you really can’t go wrong.
— Isshin Teshima
**Best Beer: The Green Leafe**
All right College Delly, your game is up. We know the College Blonde is nothing more than Miller Lite with a fancy tap. Or is it High Life? No matter. We’re already heading elsewhere — to the Green Leafe, where they serve real beer. Its wide selection of brands — nearly 30 on tap and another 100, give or take, in bottles — make it the best place in Williamsburg to grab a drink. Not the cheapest, but definitely the best.
It’s all about the selection and the atmosphere, which is downright convivial. Warm wood paneling and the burble of conversation make those IPAs all the more flavorful. We’re big fans of the hand pump, too. It serves up beer the way it was meant to be enjoyed — without forced carbonation. And that reminds us: At the Leafe, our elitist sensibilities remain intact. Bud Light’s the only cheap beer on the list, and no one’s going to start playing quarters two tables over. Good beer deserves better than that, anyway. So, College Delly, we’re sorry. While we find your sketchiness endearing, when we’re looking for a great beer, we’re going to the Leafe.
— Andy Peters
**Best Parent’s Restaurant: Fat Canary**
Williamsburg’s wide array of dining options certainly comes in handy when the folks are visiting, but when trying to please the parents, the Fat Canary on Duke of Gloucester Street trumps all. Owned and operated by the same crew as the Cheese Shop, the Fat Canary offers upscale, luxurious dining that is sure to please the family. Frommer’s has called it Williamsburg’s best restaurant, and it’s not hard to figure out why.
While the prices are somewhat steep (expect to pay $25 to $30 for entrees), they are generally worth every penny. Their braised lamb shank and pan-seared sea scallops are among the best of their entrees, and the large bar area is a great place to sip on a cocktail or enjoy some of the Fat Canary’s superb wine collection.
But perhaps the best part of this popular hotspot is its dessert. While its neighbor from across the square — The Trellis — is often believed to have the best dessert in Williamsburg, the Fat Canary is no slouch. Even if you’re just stopping in for dessert after another meal, you’re sure to find something new and delicious for the sweet tooth in your family.
— Alexander Ely
**Best Coffee: Aromas**
Tables crowd the aging hardwood floor of Aromas, and chairs constantly knock into each other as people maneuver across the cluttered room — evidence of the coffee shop’s popularity. The warm yellow walls and exposed ventilation system complete the cozy feel of the coffee shop. This charming ambiance — accented by live jazz on Tuesday nights — is by far Aromas’ strongest selling-point. The coffee itself is subpar at best. The menu presents a variety of interesting combinations, including a “Honey Do” Latte, Snickers Latte and Almond Joy Latte. Notice a trend there? Aromas recipes rely on a heavy dose of sugar. Nearly every drink — not to mention the desserts — tastes as if your friendly barista dumped a full cup of sugar inside before leaving it on the pick-up counter for you. Sure, Aromas may not be as convenient, delicious or student-run as the Daily Grind, but supporting local businesses of all stripes is still important in this economy. Unless you’re looking for Aromas’ signature sugar high, we’re none too worried about the Grind’s success.
— Alice Hahn