Peniel Ogunde ’30 is a prospective biology and public policy major from Franklin, TN. She serves on Student Assembly as the 2030 class president and is also involved in ACS and MAPS. In her free time, she enjoys reading, listening to music and hanging out with friends. You can contact her at pfogunde@wm.edu.
“Routine maintenance,” I whispered in shock, shifting to face my roommate.
“Wait, what do you mean by routine maintenance?” she replied, shooting me a quizzical look.
“AO3 is down, dude. Right after we got a break from midterms!” I sighed.
With nothing else exciting to read that night, I begrudgingly shut off my laptop and turned off the lights, hoping that the maintenance issues would be fixed the next day. However, one scroll through the College of William and Mary YikYak the next morning quickly told me that whatever issues the website was dealing with wouldn’t be resolved the next day, or even the next week. Apparently, the site was going to be down for the next month. Oh boy.
Archive of Our Own is one of the most popular non-profit websites for reading fan fiction and interacting with other fan-created works. With its extensive tagging policy, lack of censorship and author-reader interaction in the form of bookmarks and kudos, it’s unsurprising the site is home to more than 18 million works. Yet, unlike Instagram or TikTok, its name rarely makes its way into everyday conversation because for most people, fan fiction was (and still is!) a hidden secret, forever confined to the 40-plus opened tabs in your private browser.
For many of us, fan fiction is our guilty pleasure, only meant to be enjoyed by the other anonymous readers and writers in your fandom. Apps like Wattpad and Tumblr were meant to be “phases” that you grew out of, lest you subject yourself to the teasing of your fellow classmates. But with newspapers like The New York Times writing about the million of stories knocked offline, articles from the GMA Network labeling the hack as “The Great AO3 Shutdown of 2026” and the official Tiktok account for the Democratic Party posting photo edits of the “Fanfic Emergency Fund” Google Drive, it’s clear that AO3 isn’t just a “niche weird kid thing” and probably never was.
So, fan culture aside, that begs the question: Does making fandom spaces mainstream change the culture surrounding them for better or for worse?
Of course, it would be an oversight to suggest that all fan spaces are treated the same and that participants within them share distinct similarities outside of their enjoyment for the fandom. From fantasy football leaguers to Comic-Con cosplayers, the types of people who frequent these activities are varied and range from casual fans to “lifers.” Social platforms like Reddit and Discord have allowed people from across the world to discuss their favorite shows and albums anonymously while forming connections that can oftentimes be as strong as the ones formed in real life. With a few quick scrolls, what once was relegated to a two-season show cancelled because “producers couldn’t justify the production costs” now becomes an online culture filled with alternate endings and newly explained plot holes.
According to an article from The Times Australia, “The digital era increased the productivity and visibility of fan culture, which in turn has largely influenced the ways that we all act online.” Fan fiction sites like Wattpad and AO3 have followed a similar trajectory in a way that’s painfully ironic: By virtue of being niche, they’ve suddenly become mainstream.
Last year, the trend “You Need to Nerd Out” flooded apps like Tiktok and Instagram in response to the “Superman” movie directed by James Gunn. Content creators filled our screens with games like “Five Nights at Freddy’s,” shows like “Invincible” and YouTubers like Dylan Is In Trouble. It was suddenly cool to be cringe. But with the unexpected wave of acceptance for nerd culture came the so-called “larpers” and rising wave of gatekeepers.
With online fandom and fan fiction spaces gaining the global spotlight, there is no denying that not everyone within these spaces is necessarily happy about “the great shift.” Communities that were once ostracized increasingly encountered people that are what they call “larpers” — fake fans of said community. On the other side of the spectrum are the gatekeepers — individuals and groups that try to control who is allowed to participate, enjoy or feel welcome in these spaces. They’re the ones who decide who counts as a “real fan” and who’s just posing.
Recently, it’s become apparent that it’s not necessarily outsiders that are the problem, but the fandom space in and of itself. In an effort to create a community of belonging and acceptance, we’ve inadvertently created a culture where exclusion has become synonymous with inclusion. We make preemptive judgements about the very people that we’re afraid will judge us while simultaneously making an effort to seem interesting without actually being interested. We’re expected to be life-long experts on our hobbies while simultaneously purporting an acceptance of newcomers.
Does it make you any less of an anime fan of “Jujutsu Kaisen” if you don’t know that the Season 3 intro is a visual nod to Max Ernst’s “Forest and Sun?” Does it make you any less of a music fan if you started listening to Malcolm Todd after hearing “Earrings” constantly on your TikTok For You page? Does it make me any less of a Batman fan if I didn’t know that Carrie Kelley was Batman’s first full-time female Robin? I don’t think so.
Ultimately, I think that’s why AO3’s existence is so revolutionary and its current hack is so infuriating. While it’s not a perfect community by any means, its ability to host thousands of different fandoms with writers of all different skill levels is refreshing in a society that expects you to skip the beginner stage. There’s no algorithm favoring popular creators, writers have the ability to remove their names from old stories without deleting it for readers and commenters often leave words of encouragement rather than critique. The extensive tagging policy creates an unspoken culture of “Don’t like, don’t read,” helping to deter our culture’s constant promotion of whataboutism. But more than anything, it gives us something fun to read before going to bed.
There’s no denying that the conversations surrounding fan fiction and fandom spaces have permanently changed how AO3 is perceived in mainstream media. But we’re still in control of the culture we create inside and outside of these fandom spaces.
There’s a popular tag on AO3, that says “No Beta, we die like [insert character],” meaning that a story hasn’t been proofread or edited by a beta reader, so it might contain errors. Perhaps fandom culture could use a little proofreading of its own. Because if we start creating spaces where questions are encouraged, inclusion is intrinsic and community matters more than credibility, maybe AO3’s routine maintenance will fix some of the errors we’ve made along the way.
