Geronimo Ritcheson ’29 is a freshman eyeing a major for government or public policy. He’s involved in various organizations such as William and Mary Young Democrats, Theodore Roosevelt Society and Apologetics Club. Contact him at gritcheson@wm.edu.
The views expressed in the article are the author’s own.
Earlier this year, April 22, to be exact, Rep. Rich McCormick of Georgia introduced the Make D.C. Square Again Act. This piece of legislation, citing constitutional questions regarding the legality of the historic retrocession of Alexandria and Arlington County, then part of Washington, back to Virginia in 1846, aims to repeal congressional legislation authorizing said retrocession and restore Alexandria and Arlington County back to Washington.
This legislation was introduced a day after a redistricting referendum passed, approving an amendment to revoke the powers of the independent redistricting commission in Virginia and returning such powers back to the Virginia General Assembly. The amendment aimed to eventually implement a Democratic gerrymander that would net the party 10 out of 11 congressional seats. However, the Virginia Supreme Court would later strike the amendment down on May 8, citing procedural issues regarding its passage in the General Assembly.
Why is this being brought up over half a year later? In this month’s midterm elections, especially the U.S. House elections in Virginia, Democrats managed to gain two extra seats, including the 1st District, where the College of William and Mary is located, and the 2nd District, which is also the home of many students of the College. Furthermore, on a national scale, the worst fears of Democrats regarding the blatant Republican gerrymandering efforts were squashed, with Democrats successfully flipping seats meant to be easy victories for Republicans, especially in states like North Carolina and Texas.
These results show how utterly pointless the entire gerrymandering effort in Virginia was. I’ve explained my disapproval for the gerrymandering effort in Virginia before, but it was deeply aggravating that the Democratic Party, the one supposed to be the adults in the room when the Republicans were fully endorsing extremist ideas that were tanking our country’s prospects and reputation at home and abroad, would engage in the same explicitly anti-democratic behavior that the Republicans were pushing.
And a major force to blame for this utterly insidious scheme is Democratic leaders from Northern Virginia and how they were major supporters of the amendment, alongside other policies that will harm the rest of Virginia, such as the proliferation of data centers. While my angry heart would support McCormick’s legislation to punish Northern Virginia for increasingly leading our commonwealth astray, I’ve also considered how this legislation could actually help Northern Virginians, and I hit upon an interesting implication of this legislation: D.C. statehood.
Currently, despite general Democratic support for it, D.C. statehood feels fairly unlikely to pass anytime soon due to partisan and demographic realities. For one, the city is overwhelmingly Democratic, with Democratic presidential candidates regularly getting above 90% of the popular vote there, numbers that have generally never been seen since the days of the Solid South.
Furthermore, Washington is a de facto one-party entity in its own right, with Republicans basically being non-existent in the city and Democrats making up such a massive majority that some of the district’s at-large seats are restricted to independents as mandated by the city’s Home Rule Charter. The Solid South comparison thus stands, with Democrats being the only real party represented in the city. This ties to demographic issues, especially with a highly educated, urban population of only about 600,000 people, comparable to the least-populated states of our country like Wyoming. With this, if Washington were to achieve statehood with its current borders, it would be giving Democrats two extra seats with no risk of non-Democratic challenges.
However, if we were to have Alexandria and Arlington County return to Washington, the situation in Washington would change drastically. With both integrated into Washington, it would boost the state’s population to almost a million inhabitants, which could more easily dispel conservative arguments about Washington not having the necessary population to warrant statehood. This large population would also provide Washington with a greater tax base and greater business investments into the area, thus allowing public infrastructure and education to receive better funding. Furthermore, while Democrats would still be the dominant party of Washington politics, Republicans would still have some more voting power in this enlarged Washington, preventing the district from having more one-party state accusations.
For my fellow southern Virginians, this would seem attractive due to the weakening of Northern Virginia’s grip on Virginian politics and thus the potential reach of harmful policies pushed by politicians of the region. However, for my progressive readers here who may be turned off by this proposal, I would argue that returning Alexandria and Arlington County back to Washington would also right a historical wrong, as the very reason why the area pushed to return to Virginia was to protect its local slave market, which the residents of Alexandria correctly feared would be abolished in Washington, occurring as part of the Compromise of 1850. Thus, the whole raison d’être of Alexandria’s presence in Virginia was proslavery sentiments, which, in an age where more people are dedicated to addressing the legacy of slavery, would be reason enough to consider repealing retrocession.
Ultimately, returning Alexandria and Arlington County to Washington would put more pressure on Congress to approve D.C. statehood, given the increased population and somewhat better political representation of Republicans, albeit not by much.
Even if there are initial pains of residents from these areas being unable to enjoy the abilities they had as Virginian citizens, I feel that the promise of D.C. statehood, where they can once again enjoy such abilities as voting representation in Congress and their own senators, but on their own terms separate from the rest of Virginia, should be enough to warrant consideration of this proposal, especially for those Northern Virginian students of the College that may read this.
