What to make of the midterms

Carson Burch ’27 is a government major from Chesapeake, Virginia. He is a member of the History Club, Public Policy Club, Lutheran Students’ Association and Theodore Roosevelt Society. Outside of his studies and social life, he enjoys reading about historical and current events in addition to dinosaurs. You can contact him at ceburch@wm.edu.

The views expressed in the article are the author’s own.

Anyone with at least a vague interest in American politics found themselves watching the outcome of the 2026 midterms Tuesday, Nov. 3 with rapt attention — I certainly stayed up late to see the results come in (something I partially, though not entirely, regretted the following morning when I struggled to function from lack of sleep). Perhaps the most important thing about the midterms was the long-term implications of the blue wave we witnessed on election night. Almost immediately the next morning, we all found ourselves inundated with a large number of think pieces from every news outlet in the country telling us what to think about the election and what we can expect now. 

I don’t want to dismiss this corpus of articles off-hand, as I think there is some value to it. There are certainly many key takeaways we should think of, such as the idea that Donald Trump has become unpopular (a conclusion supported by most opinion polls). I don’t even think we should shy away from considering the election’s longer-term consequences on the political system as it exists now. However, I do think we ought to avoid reading too much into the election and making grandiose predictions about what the results mean, as recent history is filled with such examples which turned out not to be true.

Grand theories about American politics (especially those that flatter the inherent prejudice toward assuming the majority of citizens share your viewpoint) are not hard to find, but they should be analyzed critically. After the last election, much analysis focused on the idea that Trump had built a new, lasting political coalition by peeling minority and working-class voters away from their traditional home in the Democratic Party. If such a thing is emerging, the deal has not been sealed yet: The Democratic dominance of the Latino and Black vote is a key trend revealed in 2026 exit polling. Similarly, in the mid-to-late 2000s, a book called “The Emerging Democratic Majority” enthralled liberals with its promise that their party would benefit from substantial structural advantages in national elections due to demographic change. This theory was seemingly validated by Barack Obama’s 2008 election win, but the Tea Party wave in 2010 followed by Trump’s victories in 2016 and 2024 cast doubt on the degree to which this is something that the Democrats can bet on being true. These twin examples show how easily perceived political trends can shift, cautioning against reading too much into any one election.

There are two main things I would encourage readers to think about, one for members of either political faction. If the person reading this is a Democrat, I would ask them the following question: Was the Democratic win driven solely by opposition to Trump or a swing toward progressivism among the American electorate? If it is the former, then the key thing is to avoid overreach and alienating the swing voters who delivered power to the left; if it was the latter, then channeling the liberal impulses of the American electorate will be essential to capitalize on the moment. 

As for Republican readers, I encourage you to consider whether the election is a byproduct of Trump’s personal unpopularity or a rejection of the MAGA movement as a whole. If it is the former, then the solution to the GOP’s problem is simply to find a candidate not tied to the Trump administration in either 2028 or 2032 and let them reclaim power for the party. If it is the latter, then the Republicans need to come up with a new product to win voters. In any event, it is critical that partisans on both sides do not simply engage in wishful thinking and project their own preferences onto political reality but actually understand it as is and make sure they have processed it correctly.

On top of that, I want readers to realize that political realities are not static or characterized by inertia. Rather, they change due to the circumstances of the times and the behaviors of the people who inhabit them. The history of the conservative movement is illustrative here: In 1964, the right-wing candidacy of Barry Goldwater ended in disaster, and the leading pundits all wrote off conservatism as a defunct political force. The commentariat ultimately proved to be wrong: The grassroots conservative movement expanded to include new members as Great Society liberalism caved in on itself due to domestic unrest, economic troubles and the war in Vietnam. The backlash to the social changes of the 1960s ultimately resulted in Richard Nixon campaigning on themes which appealed to this movement and eventually propelled Ronald Reagan to two landslide victories on a platform similar to that for which Goldwater had once been branded a dangerous extremist. As the conservative columnist George F. Will wrote, “Goldwater won the election of 1964. It just took 16 years to count the votes.”

At the end of the day, the future belongs to us and our actions. We should not simply read into what happened the things that flatter our prejudices, but rather, we should work toward making the things we want to see happen occur. Only then will we see the trends we prophesize materialize.

Related News

Subscribe to the Flat Hat News Briefing!

* indicates required